Way back in the old days of KBMOD, there was a community member named Flanlord who started a gaming club of sorts. In traditional KBMOD fashion, it was pretty cool and engaging but kind of fizzled out after a few months... but maybe it will work ok with the small but dedicated crowd we have here now?
So I guess the idea would be, at the start of each month we pick a game via a poll, and everyone has to play some significant portion of the game over the course of the month. It can be something we've already played or something new that looks intriguing. It would make sense for us to stick to story-driven/adventure games, or at least games with a strong single-player campaign. Then at the end of the month, those who played the game and want to chat about it jump on Discord and discuss our thoughts while they're still fresh, or depending on how ambitious we are we write a roundtable style article. Or perhaps we even just discuss it on the forum, then edit and publish the resulting thread.
Some of us have been playing through Zelda: aLttP this month in preparation for something similar, so we could always count that as our first game.